
The most common complaint I see from Australian pet owners about insurance isn’t the premiums. It’s finding out, usually while sitting in a vet waiting room, that the condition they’re claiming for has been excluded because of something that happened before the policy started.
Pre-existing conditions are the part of pet insurance that most people understand least and most insurers explain least clearly. This is my attempt to fix that.
What counts as a pre-existing condition
A pre-existing condition is any illness, injury, or symptom that existed before your policy’s start date, or before the end of your waiting period.
That definition is broader than most people expect. Formally diagnosed conditions are only part of it. It also includes:
- Symptoms your vet noted in your pet’s records, even if no diagnosis was made
- Conditions that were investigated but not yet confirmed
- Anything your vet described as “monitoring” or “watching”
- Injuries that were treated and considered resolved
If your dog had a limping episode two years ago, your insurer may treat any future joint or ligament issues as related and therefore excluded. If your cat had a single urinary tract infection before you took out cover, urinary conditions may be off the table going forward.
The practical implication: your pet’s vet history is your insurer’s first point of reference when assessing a claim. Anything in that history can potentially become an exclusion.
Bilateral conditions: the one that catches most people off guard
This is where it gets genuinely unfair, and it’s worth knowing about before you sign anything.
Most Australian insurers treat what are called bilateral conditions, conditions that can affect both sides of the body, as a single condition for the purpose of exclusions. If your dog has had a cruciate ligament injury on the left leg, the right leg may be treated as part of the same condition and excluded as well.
The same logic applies to hips, knees, elbows, and eyes. RSPCA’s PDS is explicit on this: if a condition shows in one ear before your policy starts, a subsequent infection in the other ear is still considered pre-existing. How this is applied in practice varies between insurers, so it’s worth checking the Product Disclosure Statement specifically for how bilateral conditions are defined before you buy.
Bilateral wording matters most for chondrodystrophic breeds where intervertebral disc disease can recur at different disc locations across a dog’s lifetime. I’ve written a separate guide on whether IVDD is covered by pet insurance, and it walks through the specific PDS clauses to search for before you buy.
The difference between temporary and permanent exclusions
Here’s something most people don’t realise: pre-existing condition exclusions aren’t always permanent.
Some insurers distinguish between conditions that are:
Chronic or ongoing, these stay excluded permanently. Diabetes, epilepsy, heart disease, arthritis, hip dysplasia. If your pet has been diagnosed and the condition is managed rather than cured, it will be excluded for the life of the policy.
Temporary or cured, these may be reviewable after a set period. RSPCA requires an 18-month symptom-free period before a temporary condition can be reconsidered. Pet Circle flags reviewable conditions directly on your Certificate of Insurance, including the earliest date you can request a review and what supporting information you’ll need, so you know upfront which conditions might eventually be lifted rather than finding out later. PetsOnMe covers fully-cured temporary conditions but applies this on a case-by-case basis rather than a fixed review timeline.
The key word is “may.” There’s no standard across the industry. Some insurers review temporary exclusions automatically at renewal. Others require you to apply for a review and provide supporting vet records. Some don’t review them at all.
Check the PDS for the specific language around this. Look for phrases like “no longer pre-existing” or “symptom-free period.” If that language isn’t in there, assume the exclusion is permanent.
How insurers find out about pre-existing conditions
Pet insurance in Australia works differently from some overseas markets. Most insurers don’t require a vet check before issuing a policy. You don’t need to declare your pet’s full health history upfront in most cases.
What they do instead is assess at the point of claim.
When you submit a claim, your insurer can request your pet’s full vet history. They will look back through that history and determine whether anything related to the current claim existed before your policy started.
This is not them looking for reasons to deny you. It’s genuinely how the system works. But it does mean you can take out a policy believing your pet is healthy and unexcluded, then discover at claim time that something in the records changes that.
The best way to protect yourself: before you take out a policy, ask your vet for a summary of your pet’s history. Know what’s in there. If anything looks like it could be flagged, joint issues, digestive problems, skin conditions, ask the insurer directly how they’d treat it before you buy.
What “waiting periods” mean for this
Waiting periods add another layer to the pre-existing condition question.
Most Australian pet insurance policies have waiting periods for illness, commonly 30 days. During that period, any condition that develops is treated as pre-existing and excluded.
Accidents typically have a much shorter waiting period, sometimes 24 to 48 hours.
Some conditions have extended waiting periods. Cruciate ligament injuries are commonly subject to a 6-month waiting period in Australia. Tick paralysis cover sometimes has its own waiting period too.
The practical effect: if your dog starts limping three weeks after you take out cover, the claim is likely to be denied because you’re inside the 30-day illness waiting period. That condition is then treated as pre-existing going forward.
If you own a Dachshund, the timing of your policy matters more than most breeds. IVDD, the spinal condition that affects around 1 in 4 Dachshunds, has a 6-month orthopaedic waiting period. Our Dachshund pet insurance guide covers what that means in practice and what real premiums look like.
How this plays out with older dogs
Pre-existing condition exclusions matter most when insuring an older dog for the first time, which is why this comes up so often in the context of senior pet insurance.
An older dog has a longer vet history. The longer that history, the more conditions an insurer can potentially point to when assessing a claim. A dog that’s had two or three significant vet visits in its life will generally have more exclusions applied than a puppy with a clean bill of health.
This is one of the main reasons I keep saying: insure early. Every year you wait is another year of vet records that becomes available for an insurer to flag.
If you’re insuring an older dog for the first time, ask for a written list of exclusions before the policy starts. Good insurers will provide this. It gives you certainty about what’s covered rather than finding out at claim time.
Can you appeal a pre-existing condition exclusion?
Yes, and it’s worth doing if you think an exclusion has been applied incorrectly.
The process varies by insurer but generally involves:
- Getting a letter from your vet confirming the condition is resolved and has been symptom-free for a specified period
- Submitting a formal review request to the insurer
- Waiting for their assessment (this can take several weeks)
If your insurer rejects the appeal and you believe it’s wrong, you can escalate to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA). Pet insurance is regulated financial product in Australia and AFCA handles disputes. It’s a free service and insurers take it seriously.
What to look for in a policy
When comparing policies specifically on pre-existing conditions, check these things:
Does the insurer offer a pre-policy health assessment? Some will review your pet’s history upfront and give you a written list of exclusions before you commit. Pet Circle goes a step further, you can request a pre-existing conditions assessment during the 30-day cooling-off period, before you’ve fully committed to the policy. That’s worth doing if your pet has any vet history, so you know exactly what’s excluded before you’re locked in.
How are temporary conditions handled? Is there a defined symptom-free period after which a condition is reviewed? Or is everything excluded permanently?
Does the policy apply bilateral exclusions? This matters if your breed is prone to joint issues, which covers a large number of Australian dogs.
What’s the waiting period for cruciate ligament injuries? Six months is common. Some insurers apply even longer periods.
The bottom line
Pre-existing condition exclusions are not negotiable once a policy is in place. They’re applied based on your pet’s history at the time of claim, not at the time of purchase in most cases.
The two things that protect you most: insure while your pet is young and healthy, and read the PDS before you need to use it.
If you’re a new pet owner trying to decide where to start, Pet Circle Insurance offers clear policy documentation and strong annual limits. PetsOnMe is worth comparing. Both are competitive for dogs without existing health conditions. The earlier you get cover in place, the fewer exclusions you’re likely to face.
I earn a small commission if you purchase through these links, at no extra cost to you.
Get a quote from Pet Circle →
Compare options on PetsOnMe →
Are pre-existing conditions ever covered by pet insurance in Australia?
Most Australian insurers exclude all pre-existing conditions. Some will review temporary conditions after a defined symptom-free period, check the PDS for specific language around this.
What if my pet develops a condition during the waiting period?
Any condition that develops during the waiting period is treated as pre-existing and excluded from cover. This is standard across the industry.
Can an insurer add new exclusions after my policy starts?
At renewal, an insurer can apply new exclusions based on claims made during the previous period. If your dog was treated for something during the year, that condition may be excluded at the next renewal. This is legal and relatively common.
Does switching insurers affect my pre-existing condition exclusions?
Yes, and significantly. If you switch insurers, you’re starting a new policy. Everything in your pet’s history up to that point becomes a potential pre-existing exclusion under the new insurer. Conditions your old insurer had accepted and paid claims for may be excluded by a new one. This is the main reason not to switch lightly.
What’s the difference between a condition exclusion and a policy limit?
A condition exclusion means specific treatments aren’t covered at all. A policy limit is a cap on how much the insurer will pay, either per condition, per year, or over the life of the policy. Both matter. A policy can cover a condition in principle but still leave you exposed if the annual limit is too low.
Related reading: